Every Canadian wants our country to be taken seriously on the world stage. Yet decades of declining military investment have left the Canadian Armed Forces at their smallest, oldest, and least capable point in history. The newest incarnation of a Liberal government promised defence reform: a commitment to spend 2% of GDP on defence, establish a new procurement agency, and reduce dependence on the United States. These were promises of sovereignty and self-reliance.
Instead, we look like Fools and Cowards.
Trapped by Politics
The F-35 review may have seemed politically expedient last April. Now it has become a trap. If the Prime Minister continues with the F-35 program, critics will claim he capitulated to American pressure. If he cancels it, Canada will regress in military capability, waste hundreds of millions on supporting two incompatible fleets, and forfeit the high-tech jobs the F-35 program has already brought to Canadian workers.
The evidence is mounting. The Chief of Defence Staff recently briefed the Prime Minister on 5th Gen superiority. Stephen Fuhr traveled to Fort Worth, Texas, for highly classified F-35 briefings and learned an uncomfortable truth: 4th Gen fighters like the Gripen face near-certain death in modern combat. Only in a 5th Gen F-35 will Royal Canadian Air Force pilots have a fighting chance to survive.
How can any government justify stepping backward to a 4th Gen fighter designed in the 1980s when our allies are moving forward? Denmark just ordered 16 additional F-35s. Belgium added 11 more. Even the Czech Republic, which currently flies Gripens, chose the F-35 over newer Gripens.
The Stealth Question
Does stealth matter? Look at every advanced fighter design emerging from the United States, United Kingdom, France, Russia, and China. None resemble the Gripen, Rafale, or Eurofighter with their canards and conventional profiles. They all look like the F-35. Perhaps that tells us something.
Saab claims they don’t categorize fighters by generation. The rest of the Western air forces do. So do our adversaries in Russia and China. Only one country would be naive enough to believe that technological regression is acceptable. Only Canada.
The Economics Don’t Add Up
Industry Minister Mélanie Joly wants to renegotiate economic benefits with Lockheed Martin and the U.S. government. But the F-35 contract is with the United States government, not Lockheed Martin directly. Surely, she and officials in the government realize that. Canada has already earned millions from the F-35 program over two decades—Canadian parts are on every F-35 ever built, yet we have yet to receive one for ourselves. What leverage does she imagine we have? Canada has milked the F-35 program for decades and stiff-armed committing to the program.
https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/joly-f-35-program-economy-9.6938213
If Canada cancels future F-35 orders, those Canadian manufacturing contracts end immediately. How would assembling a small fleet of orphan Gripens compensate for losing work on 3,000+ F-35s in the global program? The math doesn’t work.
Consider the hidden costs: Gripen E remains in flight testing with undisclosed results. Supporting two separate fleets would require duplicate training programs, separate supply chains, and twice the personnel—personnel the RCAF doesn’t have. Saab openly admits the Gripen E costs 90 million euros each, more expensive than the F-35. We wouldn’t save a penny. Integrating a non-U.S. fighter into NORAD would cost hundreds of millions more and deliver less capability than the F-35 offers today.
The Human Cost
No member of the Royal Canadian Air Force supports the Gripen over the F-35. Not one.
This brings us to the most difficult question: What is a life worth? Our government cannot gamble with the lives of Canadian pilots who will be sent into combat in inferior aircraft. They deserve the best chance of survival we can give them.
Time for Sanity
We stand at a crossroads between mediocrity and a return to greatness. Canada has a sad history of choosing the former. We just can’t help ourselves. Within the halls of NATO, Canadians are viewed as Fools. To our allies who have to defend our country, we are Cowards. In a time of global instability, with real threats emerging, we cannot afford political games with our national defence.
At what point in time will the Prime Minister end this folly. Commit to the F-35. Move forward. Give our the RCAF the capability and the fighter pilots the tools they need to survive and win. Give Canada the credible defence capability a sovereign nation requires.
There are real battles to fight in this chaotic world. Let’s not waste our energy fighting ourselves.
I have followed the F35 story for several years. Parts are being made in Waterloo Region for the F35. Our Air Force needs and deserves the best and that is the F35, not the Gryphon.
Absolutely Mr. Flynn!
I would even add the following to your excellent article:
– The only countries in the world that have shown interest in the Gripen E are third (3rd) world countries. Namely Thailand, Peru and Colombia. And this is because such countries don’t have access to the F-35. For instance, Thailand tried to acquire F-35s but this wasn’t allowed.
There’s not a single European country or any other first world country in the world that’s interested in the Gripen E. Not one! Except Canada it seems from all this “rubbish” talks.
Another point is that Saab’s main partner within the Gripen E program is the Brazilian Embraer which is one of Canada’s aerospace industry (such as Bombardier) biggest competitor! Is Canada going to give a bonus to one it’s main competitors while at the same time harm several Canadian companies (around 30 if I’m not mistaken) that participate in the F-35 program?
Anyway, does Canada wants to have a first (1st) world Air Force and a third (3rd) world Air Force?
why are cowards?