It’s Just Math – 20 to 1

If people were to understand one key metric when comparing the 5th Gen F-35 to legacy fighters like Gripen, Rafale, or Typhoon, it would be the Exchange Ratio—an indicator of combat effectiveness describing how many adversaries a fighter can kill versus how many are lost. Canadians would think of this Survivability Ratio.

Our observations stem from the capabilities demonstrated by our forces and aircrew during large force exercises, where we challenge our best fighters against the most capable adversary aircraft flown by the most talented adversary pilots. These mission sets reflect high-threat, contested environments our forces would encounter in the future, featuring air and ground threats similar to those posed by our enemies. For instance, Russian fighters such as the Su-27 and Su-34 deploy longer-range, more lethal air-to-air missiles than currently available on Western fighters, allowing them to engage targets before Western 4th Gen platforms can respond.

The F-35 achieves an exchange ratio of 20:1 on any given day against highly capable and lethal adversaries. Legacy fighters such as the Euro-Delta Canards, Gripen, Typhoon, or Rafale, see exchange ratios of 2:1 at best.

How is this possible? Certainly, there is the Stealth element and not being detectable but there is also the global situational awareness that comes with Sensor Fusion in the 5th Gen platform. See everything and can’t be seen. Comparatively, Euro-Delta Canards exhibit larger radar cross-sections due to their moving canard surfaces, exposing them earlier to adversaries.

Given the survivability ratio of a legacy Gripen E being around 2:1, it becomes evident why modern air forces prioritize the procurement of the 5th Gen F-35 over legacy fighters. The RCAF selected the F-35 based on its advanced capabilities, including its survivability, lethality, and effectiveness, which are an order of magnitude higher compared to any of the 4th Gen legacy fighters.

It’s pretty easy to understand why the RCAF picked the F-35 after all…because we want our men and women to come back home each and every time.