Following same theme of late, discussed the sad state of the RCAF with host Mike ‘Pako’ Bentiez. Talked CF-18 history, mistakes of the past, NORAD Modernization, the Boeing P-8 / Bombardier saga and then to fighters and the F-35. Most importantly talked about the problems with personnel and lack of fighter pilots in the RCAF to man the fighters that are still flying.
The RCAF Centennial approaches and the fighter force has ever been in such a desperate state in its 100 years history.

Hi Billie
I enjoyed watching the ‘RCAF in Crisis’ video on youtube. Thank you for your passion in defending Canada’s military personnel and your incisive critique of our military situation. As you rightly point out, climate change is creating a vulnerability in Canada’s arctic that we can’t afford to ignore. We need politicians who understand the need for a robust military to surveil and enforce the sovereign right we have to protect our land and seaways from environmental damage. As you note, it was Stephen Harper who turned down the offer to acquire F-35s when he had the opportunity. And CPC leader Poilievre’s judgement can certainly be called into question:
“On Tuesday, Poilievre and his caucus decided to vote against a free trade deal between Ukraine and Canada on second reading because, it seems, the deal includes a line indicating mutual support for carbon pricing and the need to avoid so-called “carbon leakage.” The CPC, for some reason, decided to interpret this as Canada “imposing” a carbon tax on Ukraine… “On the path toward EU membership, Ukraine is developing policies to address climate change in line with EU regulation,” Ukrainian embassy spokesperson Marianna Kulava told the Globe and Mail.”
– National Observer 2023/11/27 opinion/pierre-poilievre-mouth-just-opened-door-liberal-comeback
I hope to learn more from your expertise in future.
Regards,
Eric Stark
CEO, Green Party of Canada – Scarborough Southwest EDA
p.s. We did win the war of 1812.
Canada signed a Free Trade Agreement with Ukraine in 2017, an agreement initiated and primarily negotiated by the Harper government.
The political theatrics last week was a bit of woke socialist greenie fluffery that added some “Fair” trade verbiage anout gender and that endless climate crisis thingy.
Do try and keep up
That was an excellent conversation, really enjoyed it
Had no idea how bad the RCAF staffing situation was.
Billie, highly interesting and educating discussion and enlightening sight to RCAF world. I can find similar experiences when the Finnish Air Force stepped up to 4th Gen fighters with F-18 C/D’s starting in 1995. Your description of the differences between DCS and FMS are concrete and in our case the FMS was clearly the sensible way, which was needed also because of Governmental releases of certain systems and weapons. I fully agree with 4*F principle!
Mike “Pako” supported the discussion with positive fighter pilot spirit.
Yes, the F/A-18 came later with the MLU II in 2010’s.
Finally, the Canadian government announced a purchase of P8A surveillance aircraft for securing of naval and arctic regions of our country, also I believe there was also discussion about giving this contract to Bombardier, mainly located in Montreal, just for political reasons. I think that would be a disaster in making from the beginning to the end. it seems to me, that this government is more interested in getting more voices for the next election than securing our country from foreign interference. In the case of P8A, they listened to the experts from RCAF.
I did recently saw your podcast on the merge and what got me thinking about the Royal Canadian Air Force is that we should really follow examples of other countries that really take their military very seriously, like the government should emphasize the military as an important guarantee for sovereignty, despite being geographically close to the United States under the protection of NATO. An example that I could think of is Singapore, where the country spends about 4% of its GDP on its military and their Air Force has a pretty robust fleet of F 15 F 16 and also upcoming F 35s. Expanding the military by purchasing the F35 and all the other aircraft that will recently procured is a good step towards improving our Air Force but we should also spend more money on air defence systems (surface to air missiles) and AWACS capabilities.
UPATE: Nov 30 announcement by Canadian Defence Minister (and MP for Scarborough Southwest) just a few days after Billie’s critique on the Merge. Coincidence?
“Today, we announced that Canada is acquiring up to 16 Poseidon aircraft, with the first deliveries set to begin in 2026. The Poseidon is the right aircraft for Canada at the right price for Canadians. This platform is proven – and it is operated by all our Five Eyes allies. The Poseidon is the only currently available aircraft that meets all of our requirements: it can identify, detect, track and potentially engage advanced surface and sub-surface threats using an array of highly sophisticated sensors and weapons — and it has a proven track record. We ask much of the Canadian Forces. They defend our country, and they fulfil Canada’s international obligations. We have an obligation to provide our aviators with the tools that they need to do their jobs. That is what this acquisition will do.”
RE: Modernized Canada-Ukraine Free Trade Bill
Unfortunately, the CPC leader’s actions show how blind ideology and climate change denialism can threaten our collective security and end up advancing the aims of our foreign adversaries to destabilize our solidarity with democratic allies.
FYI – from the Government of Canada’s website:
“The modernized Canada-Ukraine Free Trade Agreement (CUFTA) marks a new era in Canada and Ukraine’s economic relationship and will be fundamental to the participation of Canadian businesses in Ukraine’s economic reconstruction and recovery from Russia’s illegal and unjustified invasion. The modernized CUFTA includes dedicated new chapters and provisions on trade in services (including financial), investment, temporary entry for business persons, telecommunications, digital trade, labour and the environment, among other areas. When in force, the modernized CUFTA will not only continue to provide preferential market access for merchandise trade, it will also establish ambitious new market-access terms for services trade and investment.”
Enjoyed your very frank discussion on here. I would argue that the pessimism is overwrought now that we’re pulling out of the dive finally.
Look at what the RCAF will look like a decade from now. It’s night and day. Heck, by 2030, the RCAF will have new tankers, new maritime patrol, new MALE drones and few dozen Block IV F-35s. This is a substantially renewed air force. Would have been better if a lot of this had come sooner. But at least it’s coming.
The personnel crisis is a bigger problem. And some of it is partly geography. Half of Canada’s population stays in our six largest urban agglomeration. Arguing that somebody who grew up in Toronto or Montreal or Vancouver should sign up to spend their 20s in Cold Lake is a hard sell. And it only gets harder when they get a spouse and we insist the spouse takes huge career hits for little to no family economic gain. Hard sell when the average family home costs a million dollars.
Arguably the biggest strategic problem the CAF faces is the lack of a coherent vision. All this procurement and it’s not integrated towards the development of a cohesive capability that supports goals. So for example, the the RCN doesn’t buy Amphibs and the RCAF doesn’t get any F-35Bs, to enable substantial power projection. A lot of this lack of coherence and vision is driven entirely by services that just want to keep up with the Jones’ (American counterparts) and defence spending that aims to simply spend without a vision. I wish the CAF would embrace a more niche role and design the force around it. Something like USMC Force Design 2030 would work well for the CAF.
It would be entirely wrong to assume that because the hardware purchases have brought great aircraft to the RCAF that somehow the crisis is on the upswing. It is not. I spend considerable time communicating with my networks of aviators but also technicians at all rank levels. The personnel crisis is not isolated to fighter pilots but instead to all aviators. There will be no planes to fly if there are no ground crew to prepare, launch, recover and fix those planes…all planes including helicopters, transport and SAR aircraft. The scandals that have rocked the Armed Forces have left a deep scar. Leadership with an big ‘L’ will be needed. Time to build bridges that demonstrate leadership, consistent and focused over years is needed and that will not happen in short order.
So, no, I am not pessimistic. My comments reflect what I have been told by big numbers of servicing member. Finally, if someone wants to get an outsider’s honest take on the state of the RCAF’s fighter force, read Justin Bronk’s report that was leaked to the Globe and Mail; a report paid for and sanctioned by DND. It is sadly true and honest.
https://www.theglobeandmail.com/politics/article-dnd-canada-fighter-jet-crisis/
Thanks for your response Billy! I’m a big fan.
I’m one of those serving members! I’ve seen many of those issues you’re talking about first hand.
I bring up some of the geographic disposition issues because I believe they are real barriers to recruiting and retention that our senior leadership doesn’t fully grasp the implications of. The average 50+ yr old Col/Gen really doesn’t understand what the QoL difference between our remote bases and our largest cities really means for much younger generations. I got a glimpse when a young fighter pilot I mentored as an OJT 2LT called me up to tell me he was putting in his release as his first tour in Cold Lake was wrapping up with the end of his oblig service. He didn’t see the point of spending what was left of the best years of his life living in one of the most remote places in the country. There’s a reason the pilots there asked 1 CAD if command could ever entertain fly in/fly out from Calgary like the oil sector or airlines allow.
Senior leadership only consider it a real barrier when a unit is close to failing. Like my counterparts at AETE being moved to Ottawa when recruiting and retention finally became way too critical ignore.
As a Vis Min person, in a demographic, the CAF wants and needs to attract more of, I think this a particularly acute issue. We see it when comparing Reg and Res F with the army. The Reservists do much better with recruiting.
The worst part is seeing (probably politically driven) decisions make all this worse. Best recent example is the decision to locate the new 2 Wing in Bagottville. More positions at a remote base to fill, with the added benefit of the Air Expeditionary Wing not being co-located with strategic airlift (Trenton), Airfield Engineering (Cold Lake), mobile comms and control (Trenton) or theatre opening (Kingston) units.
All of the above said, while recruiting and retention won’t be solved this decade or the next, the coming new kit will substantially improve morale and make members feel their job is a bit more relevant. An honest doctrinal change that goes along with all this might keep the momentum going.