In fighter aviation, as in many high-stakes professions, you’re only as good as your last performance. Reputation alone won’t carry you through, especially in combat. During Operation Allied Force (OAF), this truth became starkly apparent as our Canadian fighter force faced its first combat operations in Europe since World War II.
The reality of combat operations differed significantly from our peacetime training expectations. Historical data from Gulf War I had shown that precision-guided munitions weren’t as reliable as advertised. While Paveway II laser-guided bombs (LGBs) were expected to hit their targets 78-80% of the time, Gulf War I revealed a sobering success rate of just 54% – only marginally better than unguided bombs at 45%. Weather, technical issues, and human error all played their parts in these statistics.
Knowing this history, we implemented practices similar to those born from Vietnam War experiences. The “Red Flag” exercises had proven that if pilots could survive their first ten combat missions, their chances of survival increased dramatically. We applied this wisdom during OAF, ensuring new pilots flew their first three-plus missions as wingmen under experienced in-theater Flight Leads.
As Commanding Officer, I held regular closed-door pilot meetings, scheduled to catch both day and night crews. These sessions weren’t about celebration – they were about honest assessment and learning from our mistakes. While Canadian mission videos never made it to CNN, we had our share of targeting errors and missed strikes. Perhaps we were fortunate this was before the age of iPhone videos, but the reality of our imperfect performance remained.
The most profound leadership lesson emerged through the actions of one of our most experienced pilots. This senior Major had an impressive resume: extensive CF-18 experience since flight school, Fighter Weapons Instructor Course graduate, and a U.S. Marine Corps F/A-18 exchange tour under his belt. He embodied disciplined flying and professional conduct.
On his first combat mission, despite all his experience, his bombs missed their target by a significant margin, detonating in a wooded area. We later joked that while he might not have hit his assigned target, he’d declared war on the local wildlife, killing lots of squirrels and rabbits. But what happened next demonstrated true combat leadership.
Without being prompted, this respected Flight Lead stood before the entire fighter force and detailed his mistakes. He could have remained silent, protecting his reputation. Instead, he chose transparency and accountability. For a peacetime fighter force entering combat operations, this display of humility from a senior fighter pilot proved transformative.
The impact was immediate and lasting. Young pilots witnessed firsthand that even the most experienced aviators could make mistakes – what mattered was owning those mistakes and learning from them. As the campaign progressed, this same pilot went on to lead successful mass attacks, striking legitimate military targets like bridges, radio towers, and enemy troops in the open.
For years afterward, I would share this story about my close friend and his mission, until he finally asked me to stop – though he did allow me to keep mentioning the squirrels and rabbits. His example embodied a crucial truth about leadership in combat: true strength lies not in perfection, but in the humility to acknowledge mistakes and the courage to learn from them publicly.
In an environment where every mission could mean life or death, where precision was paramount, and where young pilots looked to their leaders for guidance, this lesson proved invaluable. It reinforced that ancient aviator’s truth: “You’re only as good as your last hop.” But it also taught us something more – that leadership isn’t about never failing, but about how you handle those failures when they inevitably come.

Hi Billie. I believe another element to this discussion may need to be looked at. By that I mean the impact of Luck, Fate, Divine Intervention, or, what is it that allows some of us to bring our stained shorts back to the base and others to end up in a smoking hole. Ask Donald Trump. I believe that the very best book on the subject is Ernest Gann’s book, Fate is the Hunter. I had 750 hours low level flying on the Starfighter in Germany during which four of my fellow 427 Sqn pilots didn’t come back from training sorties. We all learned from their deaths by updating the strip maps, radar predictions,etc, and internally maintained that we/I would not let that happen. But it keeps on happening. Humans are maybe the problem. We are not perfect. But I believe we are still the best option available to lead a fighting airborne force. Most pilots are not overtly religious but I believe that I am starting the Church of the Single Seat fighter. You only need to get to running out of options and ideas with a couple of red lights on and a horn or other audible warning to turn your brain to mush and yell out, “Jesus Christ, just get me out of this and I promise…”. Nothing to be ashamed of here but we should probably all think about it, maybe discuss the subject, and maybe give some thanks to whatever force guides us through the dark nights. Try not to piss off the Gods, particularly if there are some out there. Billy Best.