Every time there is a marketing push for a Canadian mixed fighter fleet, the 3Ps (Public, Politicians, Press) spike with excitement. But this isn’t about capability. No one seriously believes a 4th Generation fighter should replace a 40+ year-old 4th Gen CF-18 Hornet instead of a 5th Gen, low-observable jet. Stealth settled that debate 35 years ago, when it was first demonstrated to the world in the 1991 Gulf War and triggered a revolution in aerial warfare.

What no one talks about is the money. What would it cost Canadian taxpayers to switch airplanes midstream in the procurement cycle?

Most people assume it’s a 1 for 1 trade. Buy 40 fewer F-35s, add 40 4th Gen fighters instead. About US$90M for an F-35, about €95M for a Gripen E. Not identical, but not dramatically different.

Here’s what isn’t said: the airplane itself is a relatively small part of the total cost. Buying a fighter means paying for infrastructure, training, simulators, support equipment and spare parts. And that tail is massive.

Am I exaggerating? Nope and here’s a very Canadian example.

A decade ago, when the Trudeau government wanted to sole-source the Super Hornet and kill the F-35 bid once and for all, ‘they’ invented a Capability Gap and asked the U.S. Navy and Boeing to offer Canada 24 Super Hornets. If new Super Hornets were flying in Canada, the thinking went, there would never be another push for the F-35.

The bid made the government choke: upwards of $6B for 24 jets. No one had expected that price tag. How could just 24 jets cost so much?  Well, that tail of support, spares, training, simulators, infrastructure was all stunningly expensive; the 24 jets were a relatively minor part of the equation.  The Bombardier–Boeing trade dispute later offered a convenient way out, but the deal didn’t die over Bombardier. It died over an incomprehensible price tag. The airplane looks expensive, but the real cost is everything required to support it.

The same math applies to a mixed fleet this time around. Swapping 40 F-35s for 40 4th Gen jets carries a premium of upwards of $10B. Giving up those 40 F-35s returns roughly $5B. Net result: Canadians pay $5B more for an 88-fighter mixed fleet that is less capable.

And by the way, if we reversed the proposal and say Canada was originally buying a 4th Gen fighter but midstream wanted to swap for a 5th Gen jet, the government would face the same money problem.

According to media reports, a mixed-fleet bid was submitted some time ago. So why hasn’t the government pulled the trigger on a deal? I doubt it’s a Trump effect. I suspect the price tag has stopped everyone dead in their tracks.

There is no limitless budget for rebuilding our military. If we spend $5B more for a mixed fighter fleet, what do we give up? Do we buy less submarines than the 12 that the Navy believes we need to protect our country? What do we give up as the Army tries to rebuild capability and capacity to protect Canada? Does Canada give up on air defence missiles? And what about the lack of kit and rifles, bombs and bullets for the people we ask to fight?

How do you justify paying so much more for a 4th Gen jet when the 5th Gen F-35s are already planned and budgeted? We’re all angry at Trump, but we’re not ready to pay that price. Just like the Super Hornet saga a decade ago, it’s a bridge too far, even for the most ardent of the 3Ps.